Comparing popular leggings: Costco vs Sam’s Club vs Lululemon

Millions of people pay $80 and more for Lululemon yoga pants. So we bought them and two other pairs -- one from Sam’s Club and one from Costco -- to put them to the test.

HOUSTON – Knock-offs, dupes, imitations or whatever you want to call them, but finding a product that works or looks like the brand name original can save a lot of money. It’s why when we heard some store-brand workout pants fit just like the much pricier brand for a fraction of the cost, we had to check them out.

Lululemon vs Costco vs Sam’s Club

Millions of people pay $80+ and more for Lululemon yoga pants. So we bought them and two other pairs-- one from Sam’s Club and one from Costco -- to put them to the test.

Name brand dupes? We check out Costco and Sam’s Club leggings (Copyright 2020 by KPRC Click2Houston - All rights reserved.)

We asked one Lululemon super fan, full-time fitness instructor Vanina Soto, to see if she can tell the difference.

“The quality of the material is really good,” said Soto.

It better be. The leggings start at $88 and some are close to $140. When we told Soto we paid $10 for Kirkland’s capri leggings at Costco and $15 Member’s Mark leggings from Sam’s Club, she was hopeful they would fit, as others have claimed, as well as her Lululemon leggings.

“I would love that,” said Soto.

We got rid of the tags and since that Lulu logo would be a dead giveaway, Soto agreed to wear a blindfold. First, she felt each pair of pants. She said it was a toss-up between the Kirklands leggings and the Lulus by touch alone.

Name brand dupes? We check out Costco and Sam’s Club leggings (Copyright 2020 by KPRC Click2Houston - All rights reserved.)

But then we asked her to try them each blindfolded and exercise. She did lunges and lifts in each pair and in minutes and made her final decision. Soto picked number one as her favorite - the Lululemon brand.

Soto said while the material on the Kirkland’s leggings was softer than the Sam’s Club pair, the Member’s Mark leggings came closest to fitting snug like the Lululemon’s. But she said from experience, most cheaper leggings lose that elasticity.

“In the same amount of time you’re wearing this one, you’re probably gonna have to buy a lot more because in a couple of weeks that’s gonna start getting loose,” said Soto.

We didn’t test how well the pants wear over several washes. And something else Soto says she likes about the Lululemon brand is that she says it doesn’t smell like other fabrics.


At KPRC 2 all this week, we are taking a comprehensive look at bulk buying in Houston and beyond for Insiders, starting with the massive stores most bulk shoppers flock to for the best deals available: Costco and Sam’s Club. Be sure to check back on Click2Houston.com and on-air for the full series, chock-full of helpful information, deals and benefits you might not know about to help you make better decisions. Also this added perk -- get connected with fellow shoppers with a keen eye on savings. Become an KPRC 2 Insider here!

See our full bulk buying series:

RELATED: 🔒 Costco and Sam’s Club: Bulk buying warehouse castles - are they right for you?

RELATED: 🔒 Inside Sam’s Club: The company, its history and how the bulk-buying vision has endured

RELATED: 🔒 Inside Costco: How an airplane hangar store transformed into a bulk-buying destination

RELATED: 🔒 Crazy for Costco, Sam’s Club and buying big: Insiders, check out these social media accounts worth following that celebrate purchasing warehouse-style

RELATED: Here are creative ways 2 save with Costco, Sam’s Club memberships

RELATED: 🔒 Get the goods: 16 shopping tips from one Costco shopper to another (and some social media experts) to make your next visit less expensive, simpler

RELATED: 🔒 ‘Cheeks-down the best TP out there’: This is what KPRC 2 viewers said are their must-have buys at Sam’s Club and Costco

RELATED: 🔒 Costco versus Sam’s Club: Insiders, see how basics you love to buy stack up in price at each bulk-buying destination

RELATED: KPRC 2 Investigates name brand dupes: We check out Costco and Sam’s Club leggings

RELATED: 🔒 Gear up Sam’s Club members (and civilians): Secret codes, best days to shop, and sample insights to help you save, hack and work that warehouse system

RELATED: 🔒 Don’t shop in bulk? These Costco, Sam’s Club perks might make a membership worthwhile anyway

RELATED: 🔒 Getting a deal on Sam’s Club, Costco memberships: This is how to save big as you commit to bulk buying in Houston

RELATED: 🔒 Buying in bulk in Houston, beyond



About the Author:

Passionate consumer advocate, mom of 3, addicted to coffee, hairspray and pastries.