In the wake of a fatal shooting at a Humble gas station, the community is grappling with the aftermath of an incident that began with the alleged theft of a bag of chips. The focus is now on the individuals responsible for this tragic event, and amidst the unfolding details, KPRC 2 has turned its attention to a crucial legal aspect – the self-defense claims made by the accused.
Recapping the tragedy
The incident occurred at the Sunoco gas station on Highway 59 in Humble, where 17-year-old Mario Young and an 18-year-old are accused of shooting and killing a 42-year-old store clerk. Surveillance footage captures the moments leading up to the fatal confrontation, starting with the teens entering the store and one of them allegedly concealing a bag of chips. What unfolds next is a tragic sequence of events, as the store clerk follows the suspects outside, resulting in a deadly shooting.
Unpacking the self-defense claims: Legal expert weighs in
Amid the gravity of the charges, both Young and the 18-year-old are asserting self-defense, contending that they believed the store clerk was armed and pulled a gun on them. This introduces a layer of complexity to the case, prompting KPRC 2 Reporter Re’Chelle Turner to seek the expertise of legal analyst Brian Wice for a comprehensive analysis.
When asked about the teens’ potential self-defense claim, Wice provided a nuanced perspective: “This might not be the answer our viewers expect or want to hear but there is nothing in the Texas Penal Code, in chapter 9 it deals with the right to use deadly force, that I can see that would preclude these two defendants based on the story they are likely to tell that would keep them from not asking a Harris county jury to acquit them based upon self-defense.”
Regarding the alleged shoplifting and its impact on the self-defense claim, Wice stated: “Number one, the last time that I checked, not to be glib, shoplifting is not a capital crime in Texas, number one. Number two, the fact that they were engaged in shoplifting does not mean that they are precluded from claiming self-defense under chapter 9 of the penal code. There is an exception. One that says you can’t claim self-defense, let alone the use of deadly force, if you’re engaged in criminal misconduct other than a class c misdemeanor. Well, congratulations, that’s shoplifting. The other exemption is that if you provoke the encounter that results in death. I believe that it’s not reasonable to believe that merely shoplifting is sufficient provocation to warrant the use of deadly force.”
Young, one of the suspects, is charged with murder, and Wice provided insight into the next steps in his case: “I would anticipate that Judge Kristen Ginney, a veteran prosecutor, defense attorney, and judge, will appoint counsel to represent this young man. His case will be heard by a Harris County grand jury, which will in all likelihood return a true bill of indictment, charging him with murder. And then from that point forward, there’ll be pretrial motions, discovery, a number of settings, but make no mistake, it will begin the marathon of this young man’s journey into the criminal justice system,” Wice explained.
Turning to the existing evidence, Turner asked about the released surveillance video and what might unfold in the case. Wice responded, “The first time I heard about this case through the national media, my initial take was, my goodness, that video is going to be worth 10,000 words if a picture is worth a thousand. But when you look at it, it doesn’t shed nearly as much light on what ultimately happened is what we don’t know. I want to know what happened on there on the Will Clayton Parkway. Did the store clerk have a gun? Did he display it? Did he fire it? Those are the kinds of critical questions that a Harris County jury is going to want to hear if these two young men tell the story that would likely entitle them to an instruction on self-defense. Does that mean they’ll be acquitted? Make no mistake, that’s a tough, tough sell to a Harris County jury, but it’s certainly within the realm of legal possibility.”