We put together the ultimate yuletide treat smackdown and asked you, our Insiders, to vote on your festive faves. Hundreds weighed in and over the course of five rounds thousands of votes were cast. What began with 32 delicious candidates slowly dwindled down to two finalists -- Hot chocolate and Christmas sugar cookies. And, finally, a winner -- Christmas Sugar Cookies.
Take a gander at our bracket to see how it all played out.