‘Act of God’: If a neighbor’s tree falls on your fence/car/house who is responsible?
Who pays for tree damage? Is there a way to register your home for priority electric service?
If a neighbor’s tree falls on your fence/car/garage/house who is responsible and who pays deductible? Here’s your answer: If the tree was healthy before a storm and high winds caused the tree to fall over and damage your property, you cannot hold your neighbor liable.
This was an “act of God.” However, if the tree was diseased or in a dangerous condition before the disaster, you can hold them liable for damages. The neighbor was negligent in maintaining the tree. Home insurance generally covers this type of damage.
If your neighbor refuses to remove dead or dying branches you can call 3-1-1 for Houston’s service helpline.
The neighbor can be fined if they don’t do anything.
If you have a question, email at AskAmy@kprc.com .
Ask Amy A weekly wrap of the work from Investigator Amy Davis.
Copyright 2025 by KPRC Click2Houston - All rights reserved.
About the Authors Amy Davis headshot
Passionate consumer advocate, mom of 3, addicted to coffee, hairspray and pastries.
Andrea Slaydon headshot
Award-winning TV producer and content creator. My goal as a journalist is to help people. Faith and family motivate me. Running keeps me sane.
Military families brace for uncertainty as strikes in Iran raise fears of wider conflict ▶ 0:35
Military families brace for uncertainty as strikes in Iran raise fears of wider conflict
March in Houston brings thunderstorm threats ▶ 1:12
March in Houston brings thunderstorm threats
Texas early voting by the numbers ▶ 0:16
Texas early voting by the numbers
Bun B bringing Trill Town back to RodeoHouston ▶ 2:42
Bun B bringing Trill Town back to RodeoHouston
Hot Air Balloon Rescue in Texas ▶ 0:46
Hot Air Balloon Rescue in Texas
Iranians in Houston celebrate death of Iran’s supreme leader near The Galleria ▶ 0:36
Iranians in Houston celebrate death of Iran’s supreme leader near The Galleria
Pepe Aguilar brings charrería and Mexican culture to RodeoHouston stage ▶ 1:03
Pepe Aguilar brings charrería and Mexican culture to RodeoHouston stage
SNAP Sugar Ban | What to Know ▶ 0:55
SNAP Sugar Ban | What to Know
Iranian Americans in Houston celebrate U.S. & Israel military action ▶ 1:08
Iranian Americans in Houston celebrate U.S. & Israel military action
What weather can we expect in March? ▶ 1:20
What weather can we expect in March?
Getting your weather updates started for Saturday! ▶ 1:06
Getting your weather updates started for Saturday!
ONLY ON 2: Missing 100-year-old plaque from historic Houston Negro Hospital returned ▶ 1:44
ONLY ON 2: Missing 100-year-old plaque from historic Houston Negro Hospital returned
73-year-old stockbroker arrested in months-long child exploitation investigation ▶ 0:53
73-year-old stockbroker arrested in months-long child exploitation investigation
TIMELINE: Next steps after a dozen Houston schools set to close ▶ 0:52
TIMELINE: Next steps after a dozen Houston schools set to close
Wonderful Weekend ▶ 0:34
Wonderful Weekend
Rodeo Trail Ride Arrivals! 🐴 ▶ 0:19
Rodeo Trail Ride Arrivals! 🐴
FRIDAY FOG ▶ 1:00
FRIDAY FOG
'You liar!': Parents react as HISD board votes to shut 12 campuses ▶ 1:10
'You liar!': Parents react as HISD board votes to shut 12 campuses
Parent removed from Houston ISD board meeting as members vote unanimously to close 12 schools ▶ 0:59
Parent removed from Houston ISD board meeting as members vote unanimously to close 12 schools
Houston ISD school closure timeline ▶ 0:26
Houston ISD school closure timeline
Mayor Whitmire, Councilmember Pollard share heated debate over HISD closures ▶ 1:25
Mayor Whitmire, Councilmember Pollard share heated debate over HISD closures
Upcoming total lunar eclipse set to turn the moon RED! ▶ 2:50
Upcoming total lunar eclipse set to turn the moon RED!
Baby injured as breastfeeding mother robbed at gunpoint, two men on the run ▶ 1:09
Baby injured as breastfeeding mother robbed at gunpoint, two men on the run
Pushback grows ahead of HISD vote to close 12 schools ▶ 0:50
Pushback grows ahead of HISD vote to close 12 schools
Everything you need to know about next week's total lunar eclipse ▶ 2:51
Everything you need to know about next week's total lunar eclipse
Previous photo Next photo