Judge denies injunction by police union, city, dissolves restraining order against Prop. B
HOUSTON – A judge has lifted a court order blocking the implementation of a new charter amendment that would give Houston's firefighters pay parity with city police officers, but which Houston's mayor says would cost the city up to $100 million and result in hundreds of layoffs.
“The judge has found no basis for stopping that. So now there is a valid ordinance and a valid charter amendment,” said Troy Blakeney, a legal counsel for the Houston Professional Fire Fighters Association.
The proposition was passed by voters in November.
Tuesday's ruling is in connection with a lawsuit by the Houston Police Officers' Union that claims the amendment is unconstitutional and invalid. In his order, Judge Randy Wilson rejected that argument, saying that there is a legal assumption that the amendment, approved by voters last November, is unconstitutional.
“We now have two courts that say the constitutionality of Prop. B is no longer an issue,” Blakeney said.
The mayor and police union also contend that the measure will break the city budget, costing $98 million a year to implement and requiring layoffs of hundreds of city workers.
In Tuesday’s opinion, Wilson pointed out that voters were aware of those risks when they approved Proposition B. Wilson said that, while he's sensitive to budget difficulties the amendment will create, "Houston voters decided they would rather have pay parity."
Fire Fighters Association President Marty Lancton said firefighters are still open to negotiation.
“Clearly, what we said is the city has two options. Implement Prop. B or pick up the phone and call firefighters, so that we can work toward a solution that implements the will of the voters in the best possible way."
But Mayor Sylvester Turner said nothing about negotiating in a statement issued Tuesday following the ruling.
He said the city will now begin the process of implementing Proposition B. But he added that it will trigger layoffs of some firefighters to pay the salaries of others with more seniority.
The Fire Fighters Association said its members are woefully underpaid compared with Houston police and other U.S. fire departments.
A few weeks after the election, the Houston Police Officers’ Union filed a lawsuit, claiming that the measure is unconstitutional.
A judge overseeing the case issued an injunction Nov. 30 that prevented the city from using any taxpayer money to implement the pay parity amendment. That order expired after the judge denied it.
At a hearing about the order, Houston Police Chief Art Acevedo testified that, if Proposition B goes through, he would immediately have to shut down the police academy and begin laying off officers. He said anywhere from 500 to 800 personnel would have to be let go. He said that number would depend on how much money he would have to cut from the department’s budget.
“It's a range of anywhere from 600 positions I'd have to eliminate, which would be a combination of cadets, probationary police officers and officers of probation, all the way up to 800, so it will be pretty devastating,” Acevedo said.
Acevedo also said that cutting back on staff would severely affect response times. He said the response times to violent crimes would be reduced and that officers would be unable to respond to home burglary calls.
Turner's office released the following statement:
"Based on the judge's ruling, as this case proceeds through the legal system the City will start the process to implement Prop B -- pending a final court determination on whether it was pre-empted by state law. Make no mistake, the stakes are extremely high, as the judge highlighted in the ruling. The testimony, he said, was that Prop B will cost the City over $100 million per year, which could result in significant layoffs and a reduction of services.
"Sadly that is true, and it will trigger the layoffs of less senior firefighters to pay the salaries of firefighters who have been employed longer.
"The implementation of Prop B will not happen overnight but the process does start now. I ask Houstonians to bear with us as we work through this process while the legal matters are still being resolved."
Copyright 2018 by KPRC Click2Houston. The Associated Press contributed to this report. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.