Jenny, NutriSystem, Or Weight Watchers?
Do National Diet Plans, Foods Work?
Which One's For You?
Miranda Thiel, 20, researched all the programs on the Internet before she settled on Jenny Craig. The college sophomore said she needed someone to hold her accountable."I was eating, at the start (of the program), 1,700 calories (a day) and before that, God only knows how many calories I ate," Thiel said. "I thought that was going to help me, to go in every week and weigh on someone's scale."Thiel also tried Weight Watchers, but without much time to cook, she said she preferred Jenny Craig's approach. Plus, she didn't like counting POINTS .Working with her Jenny Craig counselor, Thiel lost 40 pounds and went from a size 16 to a size 9 over 11 months. She said her biggest challenge has been applying what she learned by eating Jenny's food to decisions in the grocery aisle.What To Expect
Thiel's weight-loss journey on Jenny is just what dietitians expect."(Jenny Craig and NutriSystem) can be helpful for people who want meals done for them and don't want to think about it," said Hy-Vee supermarket registered dietitian Carrie Nielsen. "They're ready to lose weight, but they don't want to put in the cooking work. You get three meals and a snack a day. It's good for a person who's busy."Nielsen said the prepackaged programs can be a good way to get a weight-loss program back on track quickly."A lot of these meal plans are 1,200 to 1,500 calories -- if you consume only that you will lose weight if you eat only what they send you," she said.On the downside, Nielsen said, going back to cooking from either Jenny Craig's or NutriSystem's packaged meals can be a tough transition."I know someone who lost 100 pounds on (NutriSystem) and she's reluctant to go off of it because, what does she do now?" Nielsen said. NutriSystem's Delthine Carroll said that transition is part of what the company's counselors are there for -- helping people make better decisions.One complaint dietitians have about Jenny and NutriSystem is that local counselors are usually not trained dietitians, though registered dietitians are available on the corporate level.What Do Experts Say?
Some dietitians also dislike the preservatives in prepackaged food and the expense they can run up."The price of these things -- in my mind, if you're going to rely on processed foods, you've got Healthy Choice in the supermarket, so why are you buying into their stuff?" said Creighton University Medical Center registered dietitian Joni Pagenkemper.Florida-based health coach Sharyn Lustre said she steers clients away from all of the national diet programs in favor of teaching them to think about exactly what they're eating and rely on the bottom-line equation: Eat less than you burn and you'll lose weight. But even Lustre, along with Pagenkemper and Nielsen, said Weight Watchers comes as close to true behavior modification in a livable, long-term program as any in the group."Weight Watchers is one I do recommend and support because it's more cost effective, they're everywhere, they have more longevity in terms of their outcomes, and it's been supported by (the Journal of the American Medical Association)," Pagenkemper said. "Weight Watchers is not a diet. The others are focused on dropping weight quick. Weight Watchers is changing your habits.""It actually educates you about the food groups and good, healthy eating choices," Lustre said. "They're very adamant about a healthy weight for your height before you set goals. They will not let you go below what's healthy for you."On the downside, dietitians said the responsibility and accountability required for Weight Watchers to work will turn some people off. Users have to cook for themselves, figure out portion sizes and keep strict track of POINTS. Many people may want to lose weight but don't want to go to group meetings or weigh publicly, though the online version offers an alternative.Got A Better Idea?
The experts said there are even better ways to not just drop pounds, but truly change your relationship with food. Pagenkemper said even a single session with a clinical dietitian could pay for itself in spades."We're like, the price of a haircut or two. This is your life and health we're talking about," she said.Those who can't afford even one appointment can start with the registered dietitians at many grocery stores. They are people like Nielsen who give store tours and help customers understand labels.One of the top tips Nielsen doles out for free: Start a food journal and write down everything that passes your lips.And get some support. One of the best aspects of Weight Watchers, NutriSystem and Jenny Craig, the experts said, it their access to online, in person and over-the-phone counselors who cheer you through the process.You can create that yourself, they said, by recruiting a spouse, colleague or sibling to take the journey with you.
Copyright 2009, Internet Broadcasting. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
The story Jenny, NutriSystem, Or Weight Watchers? is provided by LifeWhile.

























A teenage daughter of a woman accused of trying to hire a hit man to kill her husband has been charged in connection with the crime, KPRC Local 2 reports.
A high school student is killed and his vehicle is stolen outside a southeast Houston apartment, KPRC Local 2 reports.
Dozens of purebred dogs will soon be up for adoption after they were removed from a Waller County home.
A man tried to lure a ninth-grade Montgomery County student into his car after she got off a school bus, KPRC Local 2 reports.
A fatal accident involving an 18-wheeler causes major problems on the East Freeway, KPRC Local 2 reports.
Nov. 20, 2009: The Army may stop building trucks in Sealy, which could have an economic fallout in Houston. Phil Archer reports.
Nov. 20, 2009: KPRC Local 2 chief meteorologist Frank Billingsley tracks the rain.
Nov. 18, 2009: An openly gay 16-year-old says he was chased by nine classmates and severely beaten by one because of his sexuality, KPRC Local 2 reports.
November 6, 2009
How long will this rain last and where has it been? Check out our slideshow forecast.
Forbes magazine has released its annual list of the most overpaid Hollywood stars. Topping the list? Will Ferrell.
Professional photographer Dr. Mike Lano shares his wrestling photos from 1966 to today.
















